Pierce the bottom of each cherry tomato with a skewer. In a large bowl, place tomatoes, garlic, peppercorns and mustard seed. In a saucepan, bring water, vinegar, salt and sugar to a simmer until sugar and salt dissolves. Pour over tomatoes; cover. Let stand 2 hours. Transfer to jars if desired; seal tightly. Refrigerate 48 hours before serving and up to 1 month.
Pickled Cherry Tomatoes Tips
What herbs can I add to my pickled cherry tomatoes?
If you're looking for more flavor than the garlic, peppercorns and mustard seed impart, you could add sprigs of fresh dill or rosemary. Each time you make pickled cherry tomatoes, you can experiment with different combinations.
Do cherry tomatoes need to be peeled before pickling?
Since cherry tomatoes have such a thin skin, it's not necessary to peel them before you get to pickling. Yes—it's as easy as that!
What's a good way to serve pickled cherry tomatoes?
If you're a pickle lover like I am, keep them on hand for snacking whenever the craving strikes. Otherwise, they're perfect additions to a salad, charcuterie board, veggie or relish tray. When 5 o'clock hits, they'd be a fun garnish on your martini. If you liked this pickled cherry tomatoes recipe, try more of our best pickled recipes.