Colby Cheese Recipes

Colby is one of our top cheeses for cooking. Take a look at all of our most satisfying recipes with colby cheese or colby jack cheese today!

Add Filter

Burrito Pie

6 reviews

Layers of cheese, meat sauce and tortillas create a satisfying Mexican lasagna kids of all ages will love. The recipe makes two casseroles, so you’ll have an easy meal later, too. —Renee Starret, Benton, Louisiana

Grilled Tomato-Cheese Sandwiches for Two

1 review

Give this classic an awesome twist! Turn plain ol’ grilled cheese into a bistro-like sandwich with a variety of cheeses...


Mini Chicken Empanadas

3 reviews

Refrigerated pie crust makes quick work of assembling these bite-sized appetizers loaded with chicken and cheese. I've made them several...


Sausage and Cheese Stromboli

One taste of this yummy sausage loaf at a Christmas party years ago, and I knew I'd be taking the...


Monterey Corn Bake

6 reviews

I am happy to share this 50-year-old recipe with Reminisce readers. It came from my mother-in-law, who taught me how...

Grilled Tomato-Cheese Sandwiches

2 reviews

Give this classic an awesome twist! Turn plain ol’ grilled cheese into a bistro-like sandwich with a variety of cheeses...


Broccoli Chicken Skillet

17 reviews

You’re only 25 minutes away from a comforting, cheesy veggie-and-chicken dish that the whole family will love! And since it’s...

Taste of Home Logo

Eight-Layer Casserole

3 reviews

My sister shared this original recipe, but I adapted it for my family's taste. I like that it's a nutritious...


Creamy Green Chile Chicken Cobbler

5 reviews

Biscuity crumbs take this family-friendly combo of rotisserie chicken and cheesy, creamy green enchilada sauce over the top. —Johnna Johnson,...


Mashed Potatoes with Corn and Cheese

1 review

The cheese and corn add a boost of flavor to mashed potatoes. For more convenience, purchase refrigerated mashed potatoes. Heat...


Ham ‘n’ Cheese Bow Ties

11 reviews

Everyone who tries this yummy casserole lists it as a favorite from then on. Bow tie pasta makes it fun,...

Quick Focaccia Bread

3 reviews

Green olives complement this quick focaccia recipe for an easy pizza-like bread. With very few ingredients, it’s still packed with...


Duo Tater Bake

21 reviews

I made this creamy and comforting potato dish for Thanksgiving and it was a winner with my family. They said...


Zucchini Egg and Cheese Casserole

2 reviews

Whether I'm preparing a sit-down dinner at home or attending a potluck buffet, family and friends have come to expect...


Two-Tater Shepherd’s Pie

12 reviews

I love shepherd's pie, but our oldest son, Andrew, doesn't like some of the ingredients. So I adjusted my recipe...


Italian Noodle Casserole

2 reviews

Canned goods make it a snap to assemble this hearty Italian dish from Joann Hosbach, Las Cruces, New Mexico.

Mexican Chicken Bake

1 review

A cozy comforting home-cooked meal doesn't have to take hours to make, writes Linda Humphreys of Buchanan, Michigan. "I've had...


Mashed Cauliflower au Gratin

20 reviews

Unless someone tells you, you might not know you're eating cauliflower. Even my grandchildren love this buttery, cheesy, creamy dish...


Zucchini and Cheese Casserole

19 reviews

My daughter and I love zucchini, and this casserole uses plenty for a hearty fall side dish. For extra color,...


Onion Cheese Soup

16 reviews

I made a few adjustments to this savory soup recipe I came across in a community cookbook. It's rich, buttery...


Cheesy Onion Chicken Skillet

6 reviews

My zesty chicken with peppers and onions is so versatile, it works when you serve it over rice, potatoes, noodles,...


Buffalo Chicken Sandwiches with Bacon

4 reviews

I love grilling chicken because it's a healthier choice. I put my "Joe-style" twist on this sandwich with a spicy-sweet...


Green Chile Grilled Cheese Melt

7 reviews

My daughter created a masterpiece with her ultimate grilled cheese and chiles. Want more heat? Use a 4-ounce can of...


Marinated Antipasto Medley

Each year at Christmas time, the faculty and staff at my school has a Goodies Day where we bring all...

Magazine Cover

Subscribe & SAVE

Save Up To 80%!

Creamy Ranch Mac and Cheese

4 reviews

I came up with the recipe for this creamy and comforting macaroni and cheese with a ranch-flavored twist. My husband...